John Pemberton -- the Inventor of Coca-Cola

Pemberton - Coca-Cola InventorJohn Pemberton was born in 1831 in the town of Knoxville, Georgia. He attended pharmacy school, and owned a drug store in Columbus, Georgia. He fought for the confederacy during the Civil War, were it appears that he became addicted to morphine after being wounded. After the war, Mr. Pemberton moved to Atlanta and started making and selling of patent medicines such as Globe Flower Cough Syrup, Extract of Stillingia, Triplex Liver Pills, and Lemon & Orange Elixer. One of Pemberton's biggest selling items was French Wine of Coca.

Coca-Cola Calendar 1891French Wine of Coca was a drink very similar in nature to Vin Mariani, a cocaine laced Bordeaux wine that was immensely popular throughout the world. At the time cocaine was not thought of harmful, and doctors such as Sigmund Freud even touted its virtues.Pemberton's formula also contained caffeine from the kola nut (which is actually a seed from a tree in Africa). Pemberton sold his "French Wine of Coca" as a cure for nervous disorders, disturbances of internal plumbing, and impotency.

In November 1885, Atlanta voted to become a dry city effective July 1886. Pemberton decided he would remove the wine and offer his French Wine of Coca product as a syrup based medicine or fountain drink. Over the next few months he began experimenting. The cocaine and caffeine were very bitter tasting, so plenty of sugar was added to mask these flavors. Citric acid then had to be added to provide some bite that would counter-balance the sweetness. Essential oils of various fruit flavors were also used to improve the taste. On May 8th, 1886 in a laboratory in his house at 107 Marietta Street, Atlanta, Georgia, Mr. Pemberton created the syrup that would later become Coca-Cola.

Frank M. Robinson -- Coca-Cola's Guiding Light

Coca-Cola RobinsonA couple months before Pemberton settled on a formula for his new creation, he was approached by Frank Robinson and David Roe. They tried selling Pemberton a printing device that produced two colors at one impression, but instead Pemberton sold these two men on his product, and the three men formed a partnership along with and old partner of Pembertons named Ed Holland. It was Robinson who was responsible for the white spencerian handwriting on red background that would become the most famous trade mark in the world. Frank Robinson also took over manufacture, promotion, and advertising of the new product.

On May 29th, 1886, just a couple of weeks after Mr. Pemberton settled on a formula, Mr. Robinson placed the following ad in the Atlanta Daily Journal.

"Coca-Cola, Delicious! Refreshing! Invigorating!
The New and Popular Soda Fountain Drink,
containing properties of the wonderful coca plant and the famous cola nuts.
For sale by Willis Venable and Nunnally & Rawson."

This clearly indicates that Coca-Cola was a Soda Fountain Drink, and not a medicine that was mixed with plain water as maintained by the official Coca-Cola folklore.

It appears that Coca-Cola was doing pretty well in its first year. However, as with many of Mr. Pemberton's businesses, it soon began to fail. There appears to be good evidence that Mr. Pemberton was severly addicted to morphine and possibly cocaine. In any event, Pemberton flat out cheated Frank Robinson out of his interest in Coca-Cola. Pemberton then went on to sell his interests in Coca-Cola to other individuals, and when each of these individuals interest were added up they totaled well over 100%. Robinson consulted a lawyer and was informed that although he had a strong case, the chance of recovering any damages was slim to none. Instead Robinson was able to convince his lawyer's brother, Asa Candler, to purchase all outstanding interests in Coca-Cola. Robinson then went to work for Asa Candler.

 

 

Asa Candler -- He Taught Coca-Cola to Walk

Coca-Cola CandlerAsa Candler was born on December 10th, 1851.As a young man Asa decided he didn't want to go to college, and instead he decided to apprentice with Dr. Best & Dr. Kirkpatrick in Carterville, GA so that he could become a phamacist. After three years he left the doctors and went to Atlanta with $1.75 in his pocket. He applied for work at several establishments, including Mr. Pemberton’s drug store, but was initially unable to find work.

Eventually he did find a position with George Jefferson Howard, and quickly worked himself up to the stores chief clerk. He also fell in love with his bosses 15 year old daughter Lizzie. This caused a falling out with his boss and Asa quit. Asa then found a partner in Marcellus B. Hall, and the two of them founded their own wholesale druggist shop. A year later he married Lizzie, and three years after that he bought out his partner. Apparently in a successful attempt to smooth things over with his father-in-law, he sold him ½ his business. By 1888 he had one of the largest drug businesses in Atlanta.

Coca-Cola Calendar 1901It was in 1888 that Asa consolidated all outstanding interest in Coca-Cola, and took sole possession. After Asa bought Coca-Cola he changed the formula several times to improve taste, improve shelf life, and insure he had a unique product (several people had known Pemberton's original formula). Asa also had the cocaine removed from Coca-Cola (around 1903) when it became clear that cocaine was an addictive drug and not as harmless as earlier drug journals had indicated.

Frank Robinson was once again in charge of advertising, and he put together calendars, signs, ads in newspapers and magazines, tickets for free drinks, and he provided premiums to fountain operators to buy more syrup. It was said that in 1890, advertising equaled or even exceeded sales, and that by 1908 2.5 million sq. ft. of walls were painted with Coca-Cola signs, and 10,000 windows displayed Coca-Cola signs. Much of the success of Coca-Cola can be directly attributed to Frank Robinson.

Asa Candler had a very strong belief in family, and had many members of his family working for him. One such family member was, his nephew, Sam Dobbs. Dobbs had went to work for his uncle shortly after Asa bought Coca-Cola, and Dobbs was in charge of the sales force. Around 1906 Frank Robinson and Sam Dobbs would start having disagreements on how best to advertise. Finally, things came to a head, and Asa had to make a decision on which person to support. Asa's loyalties leaned toward family, and Robinson was replaced by Dobbs as head of advertising. Frank Robinson took the slap in the face in stride, and continued to work for Coca-Cola until he retired in 1913. Asa Candler would later find that he made a mistake in trusting Dobbs, as he would later stab him in the back.

Coca-Cola bottlers Thomas & WhiteheadOne of the smartest things that Asa Candler did was to give the bottling rights of Coca-Cola to Benjamin Franklin Thomas and Joseph Brown Whitehead. These two lawyers would be allowed to buy syrup at $1 a gallon, Coca-Cola would provide the advertising, any bottling companies that were created could also buy syrup for $1 a gallon, and this deal had no time limit -- it would go on in perpetuity. The reason Asa gave the bottling rights away was because he didn't want to do the bottling himself, he didn't have the time, knowledge, money, or desire, and was afraid that others would put forth an inferior product, injuring the name of Coca-Cola. The two lawyers were able convince Asa they would retain the purity and integrity of Coca-Cola, and further its name -- taking Coca-Cola to areas that didn't even have soda fountains. These men then sold franchises to others interested in doing the actual bottling of Coca-Cola, and by 1919 there was a bottling plant in every major city in the United States.

By 1917, Coca-Cola was being attacked on various fronts. A huge number of lawsuits were being pursued in an effort to protect their trademark & product, and the bottlers had a contract to buy the syrup for $1 a gallon, but the cost of producing a gallon of syrup had gone up significantly since that contract had been drawn up. Coca-Cola was also constantly battling with their product being referred by the early nickname of "Dope." Even worse, was liquor lobbyist convincing local and state legislatures that Coca-Cola was a health risk (due to cocaine), forcing Coca-Cola to constantly fight to keep their product from being banned. However, even this problem was minor when compared to the lawsuit brought against Coca-Cola by the Federal Government. The government reasoned that Coca-Cola had to be breaking the 1906 Pure Food & Drug laws by either containing cocaine, or by having the word "Coca" in its name and not containing cocaine. Court testimony revealed that Coca-Cola was now  flavored with a decocanized coca leaf.

Coca-Cola Tray 1903Around 1917 Asa Candler was not only busy with these problems faced by Coca-Cola, but life outside Coca-Cola also contained complications. In 1916 Asa Candler was elected Mayor of Atlanta, but the most devastating complication for Asa Candler was the fact that his beloved wife Lizzie was dying of breast cancer. Given these facts, it is remarkable that when Asa was approached in 1917, by two New York Lawyers representing a hidden syndicate, with an offer to purchase Coca-Cola for $25 million he turned them down. A couple months after turning down the offer to sell Coca-Cola, on Christmas Day 1917, Asa decided to give Coca-Cola to his children. He felt that it was important to show his dying wife that their children would get their inheritance, and that it wouldn't be going to some charity or another woman.

Asa's oldest son Howard took full control of Coca-Cola, and his brothers and sister took seats on the board. Howard was probably not the best person suited to run Coca-Cola, particularly with a board composed of constantly bickering and complaining siblings. A solution to this problem would be found in 1919. Sam Dobbs, Asa's nephew, and the same nephew that Asa backed when disagreements between him and Frank Robinson arose, turned what many consider traitorous. Apparently, Dobbs secretly met with Earnest Woodruff to discuss the sale of Coca-Cola. Woodruff was universally despised as a corporate raider, and it is also probable that Woodruff was responsible for the earlier 1917 offer. Dobbs was able to convince Asa Candlers children that the best thing to do was to accept the $25 million offer. After the sale was consummated, Dobbs was given the presidency of the company and a 1/3 voting block.

Asa was not told about the sale of the company by even one of his children -- he read about it in the paper. To a man that family meant everything to, this hurt him deeply, and when talking about it to one of his daughter-in-laws, this very proud and strong willed individual, even broke down into tears. Asa would live for another 10 years, and would devote himself to philanthropy.

Robert Woodruff -- He Taught Coca-Cola to Fly

Woodruff of Coca-ColaErnest Woodruff had a son named Robert, and it appears Robert was somewhat of a disappointment to his father. Robert was a terrible student, he flunked out of high school, and ended up going to military school. After flunking out of college Woodruff went to work as a laborer for the General Pipe and Foundery Company. He started working his way up, but was fired a year later for no apparent reason. He went to work for another company as a salesman, and once again he was doing great, but again he was fired for no apparent reason. His father then offered him a job with one of his companies, and since Robert was planning to get married he took the job. He later found out it was his father who had gotten him fired from his previous jobs. Robert quit his job with his father and went to work as a salesman for White Motor Company.

Within a few years Robert was Vice-President of the White Motor Company. Coca-Cola's board had been impressed with Robert's success at White Motor Company and wanted to offer him the position of president (Dobbs tenure as president of Coca-Cola was short lived). Ernest Woodruff vetoed that idea when he learned that his son wanted free reign to run the company as he saw fit, but eventually changed his mind, and Robert was offered the presidency of Coca-Cola.

Coca-Cola Calendar 1922Some of Woodruff's early accomplishments were the pioneering use of service stations as major new retail outlets. He also pioneered the use of the cooler. He forced bottlers to comply with company standards that insured a uniform drink. Bottlers that did not conform to the standards lost Coca-Cola sponsored advertising in their area, or were simply bought out by Coca-Cola. As in the past, advertising remained a big part of Coca-Cola, and this was the era of "The Pause that Refreshes." By the 1930's Coca-Cola was taking advantage of new media. They advertised on radio, gave Coke away at movie sets, employed movie stars, and sports hero's, and even Santa Claus. In 1931, artist Haddon Sundblom actually helped create Santa Claus as we know him. Until this point, Santa Claus had often been depicted wearing blue, and he was usually tall and gaunt. Haddon's illustrations always depicted Santa Claus as the fat, jolly man, dressed in red.

Coca-Cola Tray 1931Up until W.W.II Coca-Cola was offered worldwide, but was only popular to any real degree in Canada, Cuba, and Germany. After the start of W.W.II Robert Woodruff proclaimed that he would insure that no matter were the soldiers were, they would always have Coca-Cola available to them. Coca-Cola was already thought of as something American, and the  military believed that Coca-Cola would be an excellent means to boost morale. Coca-Cola bottling plants were built all over the world to help supply the soldiers, and by the time the war had ended there were 64 bottling plants that spanned across every continent except Antarctica. When the war ended Coca-Cola had made huge inroads into markets throughout the world, and they also had many loyal customers in returning soldiers.

Robert Woodruff retired in 1955, but he continued to remain on the Finance Committee, and from there he ruled the company. Woodruff never did like the lime light and he would appoint various presidents to Coca-Cola until his death in the 1980's, but Woodruff was always the one with the power. Over the years Coke would see many new advertising campaigns, they would see the rise of upstart Pepsi (selling twice as much soda for the same price), and would introduce such new drinks as Sprite, TaB, Mello Yello, Mr. Pibb, and Fresca.

 

Roberto Goizueta -- He Changed the Formula

Coca-Cola GoizuetaRoberto Goizueta (pronounced Goh-SWET-a), a native of Cuba, was appointed president of the Coca-Cola Company May 30th, 1980. Goizueta had started as a chemist with Coca-Cola, and in fact was one of the few people who actually new the formula. Asa Candler had passed the secret to his son Howard, who taught it to Dr. W.C. Heath, the company's first chemist. As each chemist retired, he in turn taught his successor.

Goizueta introduced Diet Coke in 1980, the first soda produced by Coca-Cola that shared the flag ship products name (this was a BIG deal), and it was a huge success. He presided over the "Coke is It" campaign in 1982. Goizueta also had Coca-Cola buy Columbia Pictures in 1982, and at first was criticized for paying too much, $750 million. However, Columbia Pictures quickly became a money making machine for Coca-Cola with such hits as Tootsie and E.T. A few years later in 1989, Columbia pictures was sold to Sony for $3.4 billion.

Unfortunately, Goizueta is not remember for these huge successes, but is remembered for the biggest mistake in corporate history. Pepsi had been conducting the "Pepsi Challenge." First started in Dallas, Pepsi sponsored blind taste test, and the majority preferred Pepsi to Coke. It was not long before this taste test went nationwide, and with the same results. Worse yet, when Coke conducted there own test they also found that the majority preferred Pepsi. Pepsi used these tests for all they were worth, and they started grabbing market share.

Coca-Cola BearsIn response, Coca-Cola decided to change the formula, and they simply couldn't just introduce a new product, because the product known as Coca-Cola had to be the "Best" on the market. Before this formula change could occur, the "Boss" still needed to be consulted. At this time Woodruff was 95 years old and was dying. Woodruff agreed with Goizueta, that taste were shifting and the public now preferred a sweeter beverage, and the bite of Coca-Cola was now a drawback -- he gave his permission to change the formula. A couple of months later, before the New Coca-Cola was released, the "Boss" died.

Of coarse the New Coke flopped. At one point Coca-Cola was receiving over 8,000 calls a day, and almost all of them expressing their outrage. On July 10th, the acknowledgment was made that they would bring back the original Coke as Coca-Cola Classic. At one point during this crisis Pepsi had even gained the #1 position as the most popular sugared-Cola in America, but Coca-Cola Classic soon zipped by them and New Coke sort of just lost its fizz, and eventually disappeared. The threat of replacing the original formula with a new version turned out to be exactly what Coca-Cola needed to revitalize itself, but this marketing success can only be attributed to stupid luck and not ingenuity.

Coca-Cola had failed to realize two things. Most obvious is Coca-Cola has a history that means something. There are few products that people feel so strongly about. A product that evokes images of childhood, summer time, and feelings of Americana. Coca-Cola is in the same league as hot dogs, apple pie, and baseball.

Coca-Cola BearSecondly, they had not considered the conditions of the Pepsi Challenge. People were given a swallow or two of each soda, and given this it is not surprising that many picked the sweeter of the two beverages (that is the way our taste buds work). However, the majority of consumers have continued to buy Coca-Cola over Pepsi. The reasons for this may result from the fact that over the coarse of a whole bottle (or can), the bite of Coca-Cola is preferred. Just think of those hot summer days where the extra bite of Coca-Cola is a major benefit, as too sweet of a beverage can be sickening.

It is sad to report that on October 18th, 1997, Roberto Goizueta died at the age of 65 from complications arising from his fight with cancer. Douglas Ivester, an ex-accountant who has been with Coca-Cola for many years, has been appointed the new President and CEO. Mr. Ivester has been described as a soft-spoken, intensely competitive, and aggressive leader. The phrase "walks quietly but carries a big stick" fits him perfectly. Ten years from now we will probably have to devote a fifth era to Mr. Ivester.

 

 

The following piece of parchment is a representation of a sheet of paper found in an old formulary book
that Coca-Cola inventor, John S. Pemberton, was using shortly before his death.

Parchment1.gif (40592 bytes)

Some Notes On Preparing The Coca-Cola Formula

  1. It takes 1 oz. of syrup mixed with carbonated water to make a 6.5 oz. serving of Coca-Cola.

  2. "F.E. Coco" means fluid extract of coca (the plant that produces cocaine), however the recipe does not go into details as to how this extract was prepared. Another ol Coca-Cola formula in the possession of Frank Robinson's great-grandson1, indicates that 10 pounds of coca leaf are required to flavor 36 gallons of syrup. It is also believed that the coca plant with lower cocaine levels was used to produce the extract. This is based on some of Pemberton's writings that indicate some coca plants were too bitter (that was because of cocaine).

  3. The cola in Coca-Cola comes from the kola nut, yet kola nuts are not mentioned in the above Coca-Cola formula. This was because the reason for using kola nuts was for their caffeine content, and Pemberton almost positively bought his "Citrate Caffein" from a company that derived their caffeine from kola nuts. (Pemberton had previously praised the German firm Merck of producing a superior form of the stimulant from kola nuts).

Where The Coca-Cola Formula Came From

This Coca-Cola formula appears to be the original formula to Coca-Cola. An author named Mark Pendergrast wrote a book about Coca-Cola entitled For God, Country and Coca-Cola. In writing this book he was able to interview just about anybody he wanted within Coca-Cola, and was also granted access to the vast archives of Coca-Cola. In reviewing archive material, he was presented with a book labeled:

Account and formula book
belonging to Dr. J.S. Pemberton
while a druggist in Columbus

He was told this was an early formula book (which would jive with the Columbus GA label). However, while reviewing the book Pendergrast came upon a recipe for "Celery Cola" and quickly realized that this was not an early formulary guide of Pemberton's. This was in fact a formulary book produced shortly before Pemberton's death, and there was a good chance that it contained the original Coca-Cola formula.

Pendergrast knew that "Celery Cola" was the recipe Pemberton was working on at the time of his death, and he was also aware of the story of Pemberton's apprentice and an old formulary book. The story went that a young man named John P. Turner went to apprentice with the elderly John Pemberton, and not long after starting his apprenticeship Mr. Pemberton died. Young Mr. Turner went back to his home of Columbus, GA., and took one of Pemberton's formulary books with him. In 1943, a son of Mr. Turner's happened to show the formulary book, which did contain a recipe for Coca-Cola, to a member of Coca-Cola's board. The board member managed to acquire the book from Turner's son, and no one had seen the book since (or at least until Pendergrast found it in their archives).

As Pendergrast looked through the old pages of what remained of Pemberton's formulary guide he came upon a page that was unlabeled except for an 'X' at the top of the page. Sure enough, he had found an original Coca-Cola formula. This is the formula that is shown above.

Pendergrast was also able to get confirmation that the above recipe was the original. At one time Coca-Cola was looking at selling a version of Coca-Cola in the Soviet Union. The company sent one of their people, Mladin Zarubica, to the U.S.S.R. and provided him with a slightly modified  Coca-Cola formula. Zarubica was instructed to again modify the recipe to produce a clear Coca-Cola, however Coca-Cola later changed their mind and decided to wait awhile before selling Coke in the Soviet Union. In any event, Pendergrast interviewed Zarubica, and he showed Pendergrast the formula that Coca-Cola provided him. It was the same as the formula Pendergrast found in the Coca-Cola archives, except that the last two items (coriander & neroli oil) were missing. It even had the same misspelling of "F.E. Coco."

Over the years the Coca-Cola formula has been changed
Asa Candler changed the formula, shortly after he acquired it, to stop imitators (at least 10 people knew the original formula when Candler bought the rights to Coca-Cola). Candler also added glycerin as a preservative, removed the cocaine, reduced the caffeine, and replaced the citric acid with phosphoric acid. In later years there may or may not have been further minor changes, but certainly corn syrup is now used as the sweetener instead of sugar. The flavoring component was also changed by Asa. He referred to it as 7X, yet Pemberton's formula only had 6 ingredients. Most likely, Asa added Lime Oil to the flavoring base and removed much of the lime juice (chemical analysis bears this out).

Asa wanted to keep his version of Coca-Cola completely secret, and he created a system whereby the ingredients were stripped of all labeling, and were referred to by numbers 1 through 9. Asa Candler and Frank Robinson were the only two individuals who knew the Coca-Cola formula or were even permitted into the lab. Lastly, all invoices were intercepted by Asa. When the company grew to the point where he could not handle the invoices himself, he had his suppliers use his numbering system of 1 to 9 on their invoices. This numbering system has since been figured out, and been reported in several books, and breaks down as follows:

  • Merchandise # 1 is sugar

  • Merchandise # 2 is caramel

  • Merchandise # 3 is caffeine

  • Merchandise # 4 is phosphoric acid

  • Merchandise # 5 is a coca leaf & cola nut extract

  • Merchandise # 6 is probably lime juice, but was incorporated into merchandise # 7 as an oil

  • Merchandise # 7X is the flavoring mixture

  • Merchandise # 8 is vanilla

  • Merchandise # 9 is probably glycerin, but is no longer used

1According to an article in the Wall Street Journal on Oct. 4, 1996 Frank Robinson, the great-grandson of the co-founder of Coca-Cola, was willing to sell a Coca-Cola formula that was in his grandfathers handwriting. However, Mr. Robinson was going through a divorce at the time, and his wife was claiming that the formula was given to her as a pre-marriage gift. A judge has recently decided the formula belongs to Mr. Robinson, but I have not heard if Mr. Robinson still intends to sell the formula. In any event Coca-Cola claims the formula is a fake. Do to clues released about the ingredients of this formula  (if genuine, which is likely) the recipe was produced after Asa revised the Coca-Cola formula, but before the cocaine was removed.

Click Here!